So, how did Andy lose her immortality? She gave it away, deliberately. But the real story isn’t the loss—it’s what she gained: the ability to be surprised. She traded an eternity of sameness for a handful of messy, brilliant decades.
It’s a little like when you finally stop saving your favorite chocolate bar for “later” and just eat it. The chocolate melts, yes. But the joy? That’s real. Andy finally got to taste that joy. And honestly? That’s way cooler than living forever.